• Protection
    • Claims Statistics
    • Critical Illness Insurance
    • Income Protection
    • Life Insurance
    • Mortgage Protection
    • Health & PMI Insurance
  • Insurance
    • Car Insurance
    • Extended Warranties
    • Gadget Insurance
    • Home and Contents Insurance
    • Pet Insurance
  • Finance
    • Banking
    • Credit Cards
    • Mortgages
    • Payday Loans
    • Pensions
    • Regulation
  • Business Insurance
    • Health and Protection Insurance
    • Property and Landlord Insurance
    • Van and Fleet Insurance
  • Investigations
    • Car Clocking
    • Project Parker
    • Seven Families
    • Work Tasks
    • Consumer News
    • Scams
    • Features
  • Press Releases
    • Press Coverage
  • Videos | More +
    • Wall of Shame
    • Reviews
    • Contact The APH Team
    • Write for us
AngryPolicyholders.com
  • Wednesday, 25 April, 2018
AngryPolicyholders.com
  • Protection
    • Claims Statistics
    • Critical Illness Insurance
    • Income Protection
    • Life Insurance
    • Mortgage Protection
    • Health & PMI Insurance
  • Insurance
    • Car Insurance
    • Extended Warranties
    • Gadget Insurance
    • Home and Contents Insurance
    • Pet Insurance
  • Finance
    • Banking
    • Credit Cards
    • Mortgages
    • Payday Loans
    • Pensions
    • Regulation
  • Business Insurance
    • Health and Protection Insurance
    • Property and Landlord Insurance
    • Van and Fleet Insurance
  • Investigations
    • Car Clocking
      Car clocking gang behind multi-million mile clocking scam convicted

      Car clocking gang behind multi-million mile clocking scam convicted

      HPI teams up with LTU to raise awareness of the dangers of car clocking in the passenger transport industry

      HPI teams up with LTU to raise awareness of the dangers of car clocking in the passenger transport industry

      Brexit vote shouldn't stop UK government making mileage correction services illegal

      Brexit vote shouldn't stop UK government making mileage correction services illegal

      Car Clocking Crisis hits passenger transport industry

      Car Clocking Crisis hits passenger transport industry

    • Project Parker
      The APH Team launches Project Parker

      The APH Team launches Project Parker

      Is my driving licence at risk if I'm not licensed correctly?

      Is my driving licence at risk if I'm not licensed correctly?

      Businesses have a 'duty of care' to only hire legal chauffeurs

      Businesses have a 'duty of care' to only hire legal chauffeurs

      The Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007, a prosecution waiting to happen

      The Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007, a prosecution waiting to happen

    • Seven Families
      Knights family are the seventh family to benefit from the Seven Families campaign

      Knights family are the seventh family to benefit from the Seven Families campaign

      Fifth family announced by Seven Families

      Fifth family announced by Seven Families

      Seven Families introduces Paul's and Vicky rehab assistant, Emma

      Seven Families introduces Paul's and Vicky rehab assistant, Emma

      Nikki Thornley, named fourth family to benefit from Seven Families project

      Nikki Thornley, named fourth family to benefit from Seven Families project

    • Work Tasks
      Angry Policyholders 'work task' campaign featured on Rip Off Britain

      Angry Policyholders 'work task' campaign featured on Rip Off Britain

      How ill do you have to be to get an insurance payout?

      How ill do you have to be to get an insurance payout?

      The APH Team supports LV='s move to 100% own occupation

      The APH Team supports LV='s move to 100% own occupation

      How To Dig a Hole on Social Media When Someone Complains, part 1

      How To Dig a Hole on Social Media When Someone Complains, part 1

    • Consumer News
      Brexit vote shouldn't stop UK government making mileage correction services illegal

      Brexit vote shouldn't stop UK government making mileage correction services illegal

      5 million tenants in the UK have no protection in place to pay their rent

      5 million tenants in the UK have no protection in place to pay their rent

      Identity fraudsters target current accounts with the biggest risk to young tenants in London

      Identity fraudsters target current accounts with the biggest risk to young tenants in London

      Police forces across the UK warn the public about courier fraud

      Police forces across the UK warn the public about courier fraud

    • Scams
      Insolvency Service bans fine wines scam director

      Insolvency Service bans fine wines scam director

    • Features
      Lloyd's of London to pay biggest ever personal accident claim

      Lloyd's of London to pay biggest ever personal accident claim

      Momentum gathers to make car clocking illegal in the UK, following undercover investigation

      Momentum gathers to make car clocking illegal in the UK, following undercover investigation

      The Insurance Act 2015: The significant changes to insurance law explained

      The Insurance Act 2015: The significant changes to insurance law explained

      From consumer campaigner to investigative journalist

      From consumer campaigner to investigative journalist

  • Press Releases
    • Press Coverage
  • Videos | More +
    • Wall of Shame
    • Reviews
    • Contact The APH Team
    • Write for us
Friends Life head of underwriting Chris Pollard argues payout figures are not helpful
Protection Insurance
Home
Protection Insurance

Friends Life head of underwriting Chris Pollard argues payout figures are not helpful

Monday, 22 December, 2014 Chris Hargreaves Chris Hargreaves Protection Insurance 0 comments 1472

Must Read

Insurance - How to get satisfaction
Insurance - How to get satisfaction
Misconceptions by policyholders diagnosed with HIV raised in recent survey
Misconceptions by policyholders diagnosed with HIV raised in recent survey
VitalityLife enhances existing product range, along with launching two new Whole of Life product
VitalityLife enhances existing product range, along with launching two new Whole of Life product

If claim statistics are not a fair way of assessing insurers on an individual basis, what is the other option?

 

I was flicking through the trade press today and was left bemused by an article on the FTAdviser.com website. The article which coincides with UK insurers preparing to publish their latest claim statistics for life, critical illness and income protection claims in the new year.

I cannot disagree that there is a clear misunderstanding by consumers as to the number of protection claims paid out by UK insurers. If you were to ask a random selection of public as to what they believe the payout percentage is for each type of protection product, the results would show estimated figures that are half the real figures.

The article in The FTAdviser featured Friends Life head of underwriting Chris Pollard who argued payout figures are not helpful. Pollard told the FTAdviser: “Purely looking at claim figures doesn’t tell the full story of what has really happened. If one company pays 99 per cent of life assurance claims and another pays 95 per cent, what is to be gained from ordering them based on the percentage?

It is fair to raise the point that claim stats give the impression that one company will deliver a better outcome for the insured’s loved one than another based solely on payout percentages. But, when you consider how hard industry experts have pushed to get insurers to publish their claims data, surely they are not going to go back to the dark days of hiding behind walls of silence?

It is bad enough with closed-book insurers who don’t publish their statistics. For all we know they could be the worst insurers in the country paying out 65 per cent of claims. As they don’t publish data we will never know unless someone is willing to go through the numbers and calculate their stats based on information in the public domain.

Pollard went on to tell the FTAdviser: “What, in my opinion, is not helpful is if these outcomes are presented in a format that implies one result is automatically better than another, or worse still, that they are actually used within recommendation modelling.”

It’s worth mentioning that Friends Life don’t have the best claim statistic in the industry. Last year for example Friends Life paid out 99 per cent of claims on life insurance policies, 91 per cent for critical illness claims and 86 per cent for income protection, with their IP being one of the lowest in the industry.

The ABI publishes data every year showing the average industry pay out rates for protection products compiled from insurance company submissions. The data available for 2013, showed average payouts of 99.9 per cent on whole of life policies, 92 per cent on critical illness and 91 per cent on income protection.

Mr Pollard told the FTAdviser.com that it may be telling you is that one provider applies exclusions, such as for suicide, whereas the other might not, or that a policy may have expired before the death occurred, or that it might have lapsed but a claim was still submitted.

“These are the kind of variables that can make a purely numerical comparison too simplistic, and we have not yet begun to consider the more complicated products, such as critical illness and income protection.”

He argued that UK life insurance providers are unique within the global insurance market in self reporting claim success rates at a provider level.

“Now we are in this position it’s unlikely the publication of claim statistics is going to stop. But what we need to work on, as a whole industry, is trying to ensure they are not used to beat each other over the head.

“What, in my opinion, is not helpful is if these outcomes are presented in a format that implies one result is automatically better than another, or worse still, that they are actually used within recommendation modelling.”

I agree in part with Mr Pollard’s argument that any headline figure can be used to an insurers advantage and be used to ‘prove’ they are the best provider in the industry. A few months ago I had this very conversation about claim statistics and how you breakdown the figures and compare them fairly with other insurers.

Take a large non-mutual protection insurer who has 10,000 income protection claims during 2013, with 93 per cent of all claims paid. Now compare this to a mutual insurer with 100 claims who only paid out 90 per cent of claims. Which insurance company has the best pay out stats?

Mr Pollard is not against greater transparency, and so he shouldn’t. Even if every insurer paid out 100 per cent of claims there will always be a public perception that these types of policies don’t pay out. Taking away headline figures won’t change perception but maybe they should expand these figure further.

A pay out figure of 100% may get your attention, but I have always argued that it is the whole package that needs to be taken into account when choosing a protection insurer. How many of the claims refused are overturned by the ombudsman? Are there any customer ratings available on how efficient an insurer handles a claim? The type of policies available, exclusions and definitions used by each insurer are just as important.

When I bought my income protection, critical illness and life insurance policies through an adviser I cannot remember ever being shown the pay out figures at that time. If my my memory is correct, I was shown a list in the order of price from the cheapest the most expensive policy available.

The industry since I became involved seemed to be out for themselves, but the Income Protection Task Force latest campaign – Seven Families – is trying to highlight the difference these policies can make to your life if you are struck down by illness or accident.

It’s joined up thinking for the greater good that should be expanded on. To be honest, all insurers in the protection industry should be pretty much the same. With advances in underwriting and clearer and simpler policies they all should be publishing the same payout stats.

The difference between them should be down to customer service and what extras they provide to distinguish themselves from their competitors. Why can’t all insurers come together to fund an advertising campaign to promote the industry and hammer home the real average claim stats?

Hopefully Seven Families will be the start into a new way of thinking by the industry.

 

Share this article:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Google+ (Opens in new window)
  • More
  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Tags
  • ABI
  • Chris Pollard
  • Claims statistics
  • Friends Life
  • The FTAdviser.com
Next article Ageas completes £197million of sale of its protection arm to AIG
Previous article Motorists warned not to leave car unattended whilst defrosting car
Chris Hargreaves

Chris Hargreaves

Chris is a consumer campaigner specialising in insurance and financial services. Following successful campaigns featured in the national press and media, with appearances on the BBC, Chris can also be found taking on complex investigations as a freelance investigative journalist. Passionate about consumer rights and head of press and PR at Licensed Transport Uncovered you can always find him fighting a cause. You can ignore him, but don't make him ANGRY.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please enter a CAPTCHA value * Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

Related Articles

Insurance - How to get satisfaction Protection Insurance
Monday, 19 September, 2016

Insurance - How to get satisfaction

Misconceptions by policyholders diagnosed with HIV raised in recent survey Protection Insurance
Monday, 30 May, 2016

Misconceptions by policyholders diagnosed with HIV raised in recent survey

VitalityLife enhances existing product range, along with launching two new Whole of Life product Protection Insurance
Tuesday, 9 February, 2016

VitalityLife enhances existing product range, along with launching two new Whole of Life product

Consumers need to protect their income as you never know what's around the corner Income Protection
Tuesday, 3 November, 2015

Consumers need to protect their income as you never know what's around the corner

Cirencester Friendly fights income protection fraud case with landmark High Court Ruling Protection Insurance
Wednesday, 8 July, 2015

Cirencester Friendly fights income protection fraud case with landmark High Court Ruling

91% of the population does not have their income protected by an income protection policy Income Protection
Monday, 30 March, 2015

91% of the population does not have their income protected by an income protection policy

Featured in
MoS and MailOnline
The Times logo
Moneywise_logo
FTAdviser logo
AOL logo
NPHA
Complaining Cow
Rip Off Britain
The Chauffeur
The Observer logo
LeanOnUs
Yahoo Finance
Cover Magazine logo
Looking for something specific?
Latest Articles
Why being on a zero hour contract needn’t harm your chances of getting a mortgage

Why being on a zero hour contract needn’t harm your chances of getting a mortgage

Personal Finance
Car clocking gang behind multi-million mile clocking scam convicted Investigations and Campaigns

Car clocking gang behind multi-million mile clocking scam convicted

Lloyd's of London to pay biggest ever personal accident claim Features

Lloyd's of London to pay biggest ever personal accident claim

Insurance - How to get satisfaction Protection Insurance

Insurance - How to get satisfaction

The Consequences of Driving without Insurance Personal Insurance

The Consequences of Driving without Insurance

Lots of insurers & advisers sold ADL’s, but that has now changed

'Chris Hargreaves did more with his onslaught on Scot Prov than we could ever have achieved on ADL's. Own-occupation is the only way forward'

Alan Lakey, CiExpert.co.uk
TV coverage

'Chris Hargreaves has become a people’s champion by taking on the might of the insurance industry. Unless someone else extraordinary comes along, this unassuming man will be my personal finance ‘person of the year’.

Jeff Prestridge: Personal Finance Editor Mail on Sunday
Press Coverage
Mar 31st 8:24 PM
Press Coverage

Protection has evolved, so why aren’t sales surging?

Feb 9th 11:22 PM
Press Coverage

The FTAdviser.com: Protection adviser pledges own occupation only

Oct 22nd 10:36 PM
Press Coverage

CoverMagazine.co.uk: Angry Policyholders supports Seven Families

Mar 16th 10:47 PM
Press Coverage

The Observer: Getting help to fight your insurer can be the best policy

Dec 21st 8:26 PM
Press Coverage

Top 5 mistakes to avoid when buying income protection

Contact The APH Team

AngryPolicyholders.com

The Exchange
5 Bank Street
Bury
Lancashire
BL9 0DN

Office: 0161 914 6822

Monday - Thursday: 08:00am - 22:00hrs
Friday - Sunday: 10am - 18:00hrs

Subscribe to AngryPolicyholders.com

Enter your email address to subscribe to AngryPolicyholders.com and receive notifications of our latest articles by email.

  • Protection Insurance
  • Personal Insurance
  • Personal Finance
  • Investigations and Campaigns
  • Reviews
  • Back to top

During 2009 our founder, Chris Hargreaves was refused a payout on his income protection claim by Scottish Provident leading to a 2.5 year battle.

Having succesfully overturned his refused claim three times with the Financial Ombudsman Service, Chris and his wife Nicola created angrypolicyholders.com to help others in their hour of need.

Today, Chris and Nicola fight on consumers behalf and raise awareness of the Good, Bad & Ugly of the insurance and financial industry, helping consumers overturn nearly £1 million of refused claims.

If you have a problem or just need some advice please don't hesitate to contact us.

Additional information
  • About Us
  • Contact The APH Team
  • Press Coverage
  • Press Releases
  • Write for Us
  • Support Us
  • Syndication
  • Register
  • Cookie Policy
  • Legal
Website security
© Numquam Desistas Limited 2013 - 2017. All rights reserved.
Powered by Consumers
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.